The Nearly-Forgotten History Of The 1842 Slave Revolt By African Americans Enslaved Under The Cherokee Nation

Published April 6, 2020

In November 1842, a group of slaves escaped their Cherokee-owned plantations in Oklahoma and headed for Mexico, only to be chased down and captured by an 87-man militia.

Cherokee Members In Suits

Apic/Getty ImagesCherokee delegates negotiated with the U.S. government in 1866 to guarantee tribal citizenship to black slaves freed from their tribes.

On the night of Nov. 15, 1842, a group of 25 black slaves largely owned by a notorious Cherokee slave master made a daring escape.

Unfortunately, the rebellion, which later became known as the 1842 Cherokee slave revolt, has remained but a footnote in the history of American slavery. After Native Americans were exempt from the slave trade in 1730, many of those Natives took to owning black slaves themselves, moving off their ancestral lands with slaves in tow.

Indeed, by 1860, the Cherokee Nation alone owned over 4,000 black slaves.

The Transatlantic Slave Trade And Native Americans

Native American Slaves

Wikimedia CommonsEuropean migrants killed and enslaved Native Americans as they colonized the Americas.

Even before European colonists brought enslaved Africans to the Americas, slavery was a common practice among the continent’s indigenous tribes, as some nations would take the members of other nations prisoner after their victory in battle.

But slavery, as it was practiced among the natives, was nothing like the transatlantic slave trade later introduced to the continent by 15th-century European settlers in terms of scale.

Indigenous people themselves were pillaged and captured for enslavement by Europeans beginning with Christopher Columbus’ invasion on Hispaniola — where Haiti now stands — in 1492.

Native American children were kidnapped from their tribes and put in abusive reform schools.

As Europeans colonized the Americas, both natives and Africans were put to work on plantations, constructing settlements, and fighting in battles against other native tribes.

Hordes of Native Americans were exported to European colonies in the Caribbean and elsewhere, many of who succumbed to foreign diseases overseas.

If Native American slaves weren’t exported, then they often escaped and found refuge among tribal communities that had remained free.

But the enslavement of Native Americans was outlawed completely in the late 1700s, by which time the African slave trade was well established.

Then, some Native Americans became slave owners too.

The Sordid History Of Native Americans As Slave Owners

Cherokee Chief John Ross

Universal History Archive/Universal Images Group via Getty ImagesJohn Ross, a Cherokee Chief who was also pro-slavery.

Colonists began to force assimilate Native Americans into white culture, which meant that indigenous tribes were expected to adopt the practices of white society — including slave-holding.

There were five tribal nations, in particular, that the white colonists found to be the most agreeable, and they called them the “Five Civilized Tribes.” These were the Cherokee, Chickasaw, Creek, the Seminole, and Choctaw.

In 1791, the Cherokee nation signed the Treaty of Holston which mandated that tribal members adopt a farming-based way of life — another way for white colonists to “civilize” the natives — that would use “implements of husbandry” provided by the government. One such “implement” was slavery.

The promise of land ownership and protection from the U.S. government was enough to incentivize many Native American landowners to uphold the practices of white men. By 1860, the Cherokee nation became the largest slaveholding tribe among all the Native Americans.

Thousands of African Americans lived in the south’s tribal territories, and there were some who lived among the tribes as free people.

The fraught history of Native Americans as both slaves and slave owners continues to spark discussion among historians. Some experts consider the complicity of the “Five Civilized Tribes” in upholding slavery as a means of survival in a world where resources were controlled by white laws.

But to others, that kind of argument exempts Cherokee slaveowners from their persecution of black people.

“In truth, ‘Civilized Tribes’ were not that complicated,” National Museum of the American Indian curator Paul Chaat Smith told Smithsonian Magazine. “They were willful and determined oppressors of blacks they owned, enthusiastic participants in a global economy driven by cotton, and believers in the idea that they were equal to whites and superior to blacks.”

Though records suggest the few Cherokee slaveholders that existed were more liberal and less tyrannical than white slave owners, there are historical exceptions. For instance, half-white half-Cherokee landowner and slaveholder named James Vann, who was known for his money and cruelty.

The 1842 Slave Revolt

Black Slaves Working

Ann Ronan Pictures/Print Collector/Getty ImagesThere were few Cherokee members wealthy enough to own slaves. Joseph Vann was the wealthiest of them all.

James Vann was born into one of the growing number of Euro-Cherokee trade families that cropped up in the south.

Vann expanded his family’s land to contain several estate holdings by embracing the laws of white settlers. His family’s Cherokee laws would have given more property rights to the women in the family, but by eschewing this, he could keep all the land in his and his son, Joseph’s, name.

Vann also dealt in the slave trade. He owned at least one hundred black slaves and used them to run his plantations.

According to Ties That Bind: The Story of an Afro-Cherokee Family in Slavery and Freedom by Tiya Miles, missionaries who lived near Vann described him as an abusive alcoholic who “terrorized his slaves — burning their cabins, whipping them, and ‘executing’ them ‘in such a horrible way.'”

Black Slave Children

© Hulton-Deutsch Collection/CORBIS/Corbis via Getty ImagesBy the early 1800s, thousands of African Americans lived in tribal territory, some as free people and others as slaves.

That all came to an end on Nov. 15, 1842, when more than 25 black slaves — the majority from the Vann plantation in Webbers Falls, Oklahoma — revolted. The slaves locked their Cherokee masters in their homes while they slept, stole their guns, horses, food, and ammunition, and ran away.

The runaway slaves headed toward Mexico where slavery was illegal. As they journeyed south, the group crossed into Creek nation territory where they were joined by more escaped slaves of the Creek, raising the group total to about 35 rebels.

Two days after their escape, a Cherokee militia — an 87-man armed force led by Captain John Drew — was deployed to recapture them. The group was eventually caught near the Red River on Nov. 28, 1842.

The slaves were brought to face the Cherokee National Council in Tahlequah and five of them were executed. Cherokee slaveholders blamed the uprising on the influence of the free African Americans living in tribal territory.

The tribe soon passed a law mandating that all free African Americans, except former Cherokee slaves, leave the nation.

Cherokee Freedmen And Their Descendants

Black Native American

Charles Van Schaick/Wisconsin Historical Society/Getty ImagesPortrait of two young Ho-Chunk girls circa 1904. Carrie Elk (ENooKah), left, is of mixed African-American and Ho-Chunk heritage.

A year after the end of the Civil War, the Cherokees — who fought alongside the pro-slavery Confederates — entered into a treaty with the U.S. government that guaranteed tribal citizenship to the tribe’s former slaves. They would be called “Freedmen” and their descendants would be listed on the Dawes Roll, the government’s official tribal registry.

But in 2007, Cherokee members voted to strip 2,800 Cherokee Freedmen of their tribal membership and moved to redefine tribal citizenship as “by blood.” The move sparked a lawsuit that lasted over a decade, ending with a 2019 judge ruling that the descendants of black Cherokee slaves could maintain their citizenship.

“There can be racial justice — but it doesn’t always come easy,” Marilyn Vann, president of the Descendants of Freedmen of the Five Civilized Tribes and a descendant of the Vann family, said of the court ruling.

Black Seminole Children

Andrew Lichtenstein/Corbis via Getty ImagesDescendants of Black Seminole Scouts who, like the descendants of the Cherokee Freedmen, are redefining what it means to be both black and native.

“What this means for me, is the Freedmen people will be able to continue our citizenship… and also that we’re able to preserve our history. All we ever wanted was the rights promised us, to continue to be enforced.”

As conversations around America’s sordid past of racial inequality expands, the nearly-forgotten history of the black slaves who were owned by the country’s native tribes can no longer be ignored.

Next, read about the Native American man believed to possess the oldest American DNA ever recorded and uncover the atrocious truth of The Trail Of Tears, the government-approved ethnic cleansing of more than 100,000 Native Americans.

Natasha Ishak
A former staff writer for All That's Interesting, Natasha Ishak holds a Master's in journalism from Emerson College and her work has appeared in VICE, Insider, Vox, and Harvard's Nieman Lab.
Leah Silverman
A former associate editor for All That's Interesting, Leah Silverman holds a Master's in Fine Arts from Columbia University's Creative Writing Program and her work has appeared in Catapult, Town & Country, Women's Health, and Publishers Weekly.
Citation copied
Cite This Article
Ishak, Natasha. "The Nearly-Forgotten History Of The 1842 Slave Revolt By African Americans Enslaved Under The Cherokee Nation.", April 6, 2020, Accessed June 24, 2024.