The Story Of Christine Paolilla, The Teenager Who Murdered Her Friends Out Of Jealousy

Published October 12, 2023
Updated October 13, 2023

After years of being bullied, 17-year-old Christine Paolilla became friends with two popular girls who helped her fit in at her Texas high school — and then she shot them to death.

On a July night in 2003, Christine Paolilla gunned down four of her friends in a fit of jealousy that is now known as the Clear Lake Massacre.

Christine Paolilla

X (Twitter)Christine Paolilla murdered the popular girls who help her turn into “Miss Irresistible.”

Paolilla fatally shot Rachael Koloroutis, Tiffany Rowell, Marcus Precella, and Adelbert Sanchez in Rowell’s Clear Lake City, Texas home on July 18, 2003. At the time of the murders, she was just 17 years old.

She committed the crimes alongside her boyfriend, Christopher Snider. For three years, the two of them evaded capture as police struggled to identify the culprits. Then, an anonymous tip in 2006 led investigators straight to Paolilla.

The vicious Clear Lake Massacre had been solved at last — and the families of the victims finally had the answers they’d sought for years.

Christine Paolilla’s Early Life And Struggles With Bullying

Christine Marie Paolilla was born on Long Island, New York, on March 31, 1986. Her father died in a construction accident when she was just two years old. Her mother, Lori, later moved the family to the suburbs of Houston.

When she was in kindergarten, Paolilla was diagnosed with alopecia, a condition that caused her hair, eyebrows, and eyelashes to fall out. She also struggled with poor vision and had to wear thick glasses.

Sadly, her appearance made her a target of cruel jokes and teasing by her peers, which caused low self-esteem. Paolilla faced severe bullying every day during her school years due to the wigs she wore and the eyebrows she drew on each morning to conceal her baldness.

In an interview with ABC News, Lori Paolilla described the pain her daughter went through: “That was devastating. She had poor vision so she had what I guess most folks would know as ‘Coke-bottle glasses,’ and started being ridiculed by young children… Classmates would come up behind her, pull her wig off her head. It was so painful to watch.”

Christine Paolilla's Family

YouTubeChristine Paolilla with her stepfather Tom Dick and mother Lori Paolilla.

Christine Paolilla attended Clear Lake High School in Houston. She eventually befriended two popular students, Rachael Koloroutis and Tiffany Rowell. The girls taught her how to change her appearance with makeup and clothing to better fit in with her peers. The transformation was so drastic that in 2003, Paolilla’s fellow classmates voted her “Miss Irresistible.”

Around the same time, Paolilla began dating 21-year-old Christopher Lee Snider, who was a known criminal. Paolilla’s mother and stepfather disapproved of their relationship, as did Koloroutis and Rowell.

Snider’s frequent drug use and extensive criminal record concerned those who cared about the young, impressionable girl. Unfortunately, their concerns were validated when Paolilla began using drugs herself.

According to Snider’s family, the relationship was doomed from the start. They cited the vicious arguments Paolilla and Snider frequently had. One even resulted in Paolilla spending the night on the front lawn of his family’s home, threatening to kill them all.

Still, Paolilla stubbornly refused to leave Snider — a decision that would have tragic results.

Inside The Vicious Clear Lake Massacre

On July 18, 2003, Christine Paolilla and Christopher Snider visited Tiffany Rowell’s home in Clear Lake City where Koloroutis, Rowell’s boyfriend Marcus Precella, and Precella’s cousin Adelbert Sanchez were all hanging out together. The plan was to simply steal drugs from the house and leave, but the evening took a dark turn when Snider began arguing with Precella.

The confrontation escalated, and Snider and Paolilla began shooting. It’s not clear who killed who, but the couple fired at least 40 rounds in total. All four of the victims had numerous bullet wounds — and Rowell and Koloroutis were both shot in the groin.

Clear Lake Massacre Victims

X (Twitter)The victims of the Clear Lake Massacre. Clockwise from top left: Rachael Koloroutis, Tiffany Rowell, Adelbert Sanchez, and Marcus Precella.

Koloroutis initially survived the onslaught and began to crawl through a puddle of her own blood to reach the phone and call 911. When Paolilla saw that she was still alive, she began viciously beating her to death with the butt of a revolver while Koloroutis cried out, “Why?”

Less than an hour after committing the murders, Snider drove Paolilla to Walgreens so she could clock into her job at the makeup counter like nothing had happened.

According to the Houston Chronicle, due to a lack of evidence at the crime scene, police initially suspected the murders were drug-related. It wasn’t until 2006 that the truth came out.

How Christine Paolilla Was Finally Brought To Justice

For three years, the cold-blooded Clear Lake Massacre went unsolved. Paolilla and Snider broke up in 2004 after he went to jail for stealing a car. She entered rehab in Texas, where she met her soon-to-be husband, Stanley Justin Rott.

The two tied the knot in March 2005. Four months later, on the second anniversary of the murders, Paolilla came across a news report about the unsolved case on TV. When she saw the composite sketches of the suspects, she confessed to Rott that she and Snider were responsible.

The couple went into hiding, living out of a motel room in San Antonio. A year later, police received an anonymous tip. The caller said he had met Paolilla in rehab and she had confessed to him that she had murdered the four victims in the Clear Lake Massacre.

Christine Paolilla And Justin Rott

Police Handout/Lori PaolillaChristine Paolilla eventually married Justin Rott, who helped her hide from the police.

Acting on this information, authorities arrested Christine Paolilla outside her motel room. Rott told the police about his wife’s confession, and he revealed to them a shocking twist to the story: Paolilla had told him that she saw Koloroutis still clinging to life and decided to finish her off by bludgeoning her friend to death.

When interrogated by detectives, Paolilla shifted all the blame onto her former boyfriend, Snider. She claimed that it was Snider who came up with the idea to rob her friends, but their plans went terribly wrong. Both Paolilla and Snider, who was still at large, were charged with capital murder.

Snider found out about the arrest warrant against him and took his own life in August 2006.

The Trial And Sentencing Of Christine Paolilla

In October 2008, Paolilla was found guilty of four counts of capital murder. As she was a juvenile at the time of the crimes, she avoided the death penalty and instead received a life sentence.

Christopher Snider

Facebook/Murder with Friends PodcastChristopher Snider killed himself to avoid arrest for his role in the Clear Lake Massacre.

The question remains: Why did she do it? Christine Paolilla never apologized for the killings, and she has never given a motive. However, psychiatrist Gail Saltz believes that her actions were driven by envy and jealousy towards her popular friends.

Snider’s sister Brandee agrees that jealousy was the motive for murder.

According to the New York Post, Brandee said, “I remember her being intensely jealous. There must have been some underlying jealousy between [Paolilla] and [Koloroutis]. When I saw photos of [Koloroutis], I knew instantly. She was very beautiful.”

After reading about Christine Paolilla and the Clear Lake Massacre, discover the story of Nicholas Markowitz, the teenager who was murdered over his brother’s drug debt. Then, learn about the sad story of Ward Weaver III, the Oregon dad who murdered his daughter’s friends.

Rivy Lyon
True crime expert Rivy Lyon holds a Bachelor's degree in criminology, psychology, and sociology. A former private investigator, she has also worked with CrimeStoppers, the Innocence Project, and disaster response agencies across the U.S. She transitioned into investigative journalism in 2020, focusing primarily on unsolved homicides and missing persons.
Cara Johnson
A writer and editor based in Charleston, South Carolina and an assistant editor at All That's Interesting, Cara Johnson holds a B.A. in English and Creative Writing from Washington & Lee University and an M.A. in English from College of Charleston and has written for various publications in her six-year career.