A Definitive List Of History’s Creepiest Cryptids — And Where They Allegedly Live

Published April 21, 2026
Updated April 22, 2026

The Mothman: The Infamous Cryptid From West Virginia

Mothman Cryptid

Wikimedia CommonsWhen a bridge collapsed in Point Pleasant, West Virginia in 1967, some blamed the disaster on the legendary Mothman.

On December 15, 1967, the Silver Bridge connecting Point Pleasant, West Virginia to Gallipolis, Ohio was all but completely packed with stand-still traffic. Built in 1928, when cars were, on average, a good 2,500 pounds lighter, the bridge wasn’t made to hold the weight of such heavy vehicles. Without warning, it collapsed, and 46 people died as a result.

But this wasn’t the only strange thing that was happening in Point Pleasant. For about a year prior to the Silver Bridge collapse, people who lived in the area had reported seeing a large, winged creature with red eyes flying around in the skies above.

This creature came to be known as the Mothman — and many believed that it may have been a foreteller of doom.

The Mothman

RedditThe Mothman is one of the most strangely beloved cryptids on this list, as the town of Point Pleasant still throws an annual Mothman festival each year and even has a statue of the legendary creature on display.

The first reported sighting of the Mothman came on November 12, 1966, in Clendenin, West Virginia, when a group of gravediggers reportedly saw a massive, brown figure darting between the treetops overhead.

Just a few days later, the winged creature made its way to Point Pleasant, where it was seen by two couples — directly in front of the car they were sitting in. They said that the creature stood about six or seven feet tall, with bright red eyes about six inches apart. The witnesses also claimed that it had a 10-foot wingspan and could fly at speeds close to 100 miles per hour.

Given how prevalent Mothman sightings were, it was only natural that when the Silver Bridge collapsed, some claimed to have seen the Mothman just before the disaster. Could the Mothman have been trying to warn the people of Point Pleasant, or was it a more sinister harbinger of doom?

The Jersey Devil

Jersey Devil

Wikimedia CommonsThere are several legends about the Jersey Devil, a centuries-old cryptid on this list.

Somewhere in the 1,700 square miles that make up New Jersey’s Pine Barrens, legend says there resides a horse-headed, bat-winged demon known as the Jersey Devil. This horrifying oddity has terrorized New Jersey residents for nearly 300 years — and supposedly still does today.

The Jersey Devil has several different origin stories, but the most common one claims that this legendary creature first made an appearance in 1735. The story goes that a woman named Mother Leeds became pregnant with her 13th child, but because her husband was a drunk and couldn’t provide for his family, they had fallen on hard times. In a bout of desperate frustration, Mother Leeds shouted, “Let this child be the devil!”

Mother Leeds’ prayer (or curse) was answered, as her 13th child was born as a winged beast with a long tail and talons. Though she tried to confine the beast to her home, it eventually killed her and escaped into the woods.

Another version of the story claims that Mother Leeds was a witch who said the child’s father was the Devil himself. And another tale tells of an affair between a New Jersey woman and a British soldier. The townsfolk cursed their love, and when the woman bore a child, it became the Jersey Devil.

Regardless of which version of the story you believe — if any — the Jersey Devil has remained a staple of local lore for about three centuries. In fact, like many other cryptids on this list, its popularity has seemingly never faded.

Alleged Photo Of The Jersey Devil

David Black/TwitterAn alleged photo of the Jersey Devil, captured in 2015.

The Jersey Devil legend became so popular, in fact, that in 1960, merchants near Camden put out a $10,000 bounty for anyone who could successfully capture the cryptid. The merchants also said that if the Jersey Devil was caught, they would construct a private zoo for the creature.

No one has been able to claim the prize, but in 2015, a local New Jersey man came forward with claims that he captured the Jersey Devil on camera. The photo “evidence,” however, is unfortunately blurry and lacking.

All That's Interesting Logo
Our Editorial Standards

All That's Interesting is a U.S.-based digital publisher that employs subject-level experts to produce our articles. Each article is written by a staff member or a highly-vetted freelancer, and is reviewed by at least one editor. For licensing and permission inquiries, visit Wright's Media.

Become a member to help support our work and enjoy our site ad-free.

author
Austin Harvey
author
A staff writer for All That's Interesting since 2022, Austin Harvey has also had work published with Discover Magazine, Giddy, and Lucid, covering topics including history, and sociology. He has published more than 1,000 pieces, largely covering modern history and archaeology. He is a co-host of the History Uncovered podcast as well as a co-host and founder of the Conspiracy Realists podcast. He holds a Bachelor's degree from Point Park University. He is based in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
editor
John Kuroski
editor
Based in Brooklyn, New York, John Kuroski is the editorial director of All That's Interesting. He graduated from New York University with a degree in history, earning a place in the Phi Alpha Theta honor society for history students. An editor at All That's Interesting since 2015, his areas of expertise include modern American history and the ancient Near East. In an editing career spanning 17 years, he previously served as managing editor of Elmore Magazine in New York City for seven years.
Citation copied
COPY
Cite This Article
Harvey, Austin. "A Definitive List Of History’s Creepiest Cryptids — And Where They Allegedly Live." AllThatsInteresting.com, April 21, 2026, https://allthatsinteresting.com/cryptids. Accessed April 26, 2026.