6 Unsolved Murder Cases That Will Keep You Up At Night

Published October 5, 2021
Updated April 3, 2024

The Hall-Mills Murder Case

Hall-Mills Unsolved Murders

NY Daily News Archive via Getty ImagesThe site in New Brunswick, New Jersey where the bodies of the Rev. Edward Hall and Mrs. Eleanor Mills were found after they were murdered.

On September 16, 1922, two teenage lovers were out on a stroll when they discovered the bodies of a man and a woman lying under a crab apple tree. Both the man and the woman were dead; the man was shot once, the woman three times.

The bodies had been posed: Both the man’s and the woman’s feet were pointing towards the apple tree, the man’s hand was on the woman’s neck and hers on his knee. The man’s card was propped against his foot. A hat concealed the man’s head, and a scarf was wrapped around the woman’s neck. It was later discovered that the woman’s tongue had been cut out. Torn love letters were scattered all around them.

Sketch of Reverend Edward Wheeler Hall and Eleanor Reinhardt Mills

Bettmann/Getty ImagesContemporary artist’s conception of how the victims were killed.

The bodies were those of Reverend Edward Wheeler Hall and Eleanor Reinhardt Mills. The two had been lovers, but their affair was a complicated one. Mills was married to the church’s janitor, and Hall was married to a wealthy woman named Frances Stevens Hall, the main murder suspect.

Eleanor Reinhardt Mills

Creative CommonsEleanor Reinhardt Mills, the wife of James Mills and Reverend Hall’s lover.

The crime scene was contaminated by souvenir hunters, and thus the police had nothing solid to go on until Jane Gibson, better known as the “Pig Woman,” came forward. She was a hog farmer who lived near the crime scene.

According to her, on the night of September 14, she saw four people, two men and two women, in her cornfield. Gibson heard a woman yell “Explain these letters,” gunshots, and then a woman shrieking “Henry!”

Frances Noel Stevens Hall

Creative CommonsFrances Noel Stevens Hall, widow of victim Reverend Edward Wheeler Hall, a suspect in the murders.

The case was dismissed and no one was charged. But then, four years later, a maid that had previously served the Halls confessed that the reverend wanted to annul his marriage and elope with Mills.

The Pig Woman was once again called in to testify but her testimony was deemed inaccurate. It didn’t help that Gibson’s mother, who sat in the front row, kept mumbling “liar, liar” throughout the testimony, thus further ruining Gibson’s credibility. Mrs. Hall and her brothers, Henry and William, were acquitted.

Laura Martisiute
Laura Martisiute is a freelance writer based in Tramore, Ireland. In her spare time, she likes to explore secret beaches, pet cats, and read.
John Kuroski
John Kuroski is the editorial director of All That's Interesting. He graduated from New York University with a degree in history, earning a place in the Phi Alpha Theta honor society for history students. An editor at All That's Interesting since 2015, his areas of interest include modern history and true crime.
Citation copied
Cite This Article
Martisiute, Laura. "6 Unsolved Murder Cases That Will Keep You Up At Night." AllThatsInteresting.com, October 5, 2021, https://allthatsinteresting.com/unsolved-murder-cases. Accessed May 26, 2024.