The Story Of Carmine Persico, The Feared Boss Of The Colombo Family

Published May 4, 2024
Updated May 13, 2024

Despite being sentenced to life in prison in 1986 for racketeering, Carmine Persico maintained his grip on the Colombo's for decades.

Mafia scholars have long argued over who was the greatest family, who was the greatest boss, who built the greatest criminal empire. Names like Joe Gallo and Lucky Luciano come to mind, but their terms were relatively short-lived. They had to prove themselves and rise through the ranks before enjoying their moment at the top.

But there was one man who was, it seemed, born a mobster and who stayed at the top long after his contemporaries died off. Now that he himself has passed away, a look back at his criminal legacy is in order.

Carmine Persico

Yvonne Hemsey/Getty ImagesCarmine Persico poses for a portrait at the Metropolitan Correctional Center in New York City. 1986.

In elementary school, he shook his classmates down for lunch money. By the time he was 15, he’d already been involved in a shootout between two rival gangs. By 17, he’d been accused of a murder. By 20, he was accused of another. At 40, the Colombo crime family was under his power and remained that way until his death at age 85.

Yes, it seems that Carmine Persico was born to be a mob boss — and that’s just what he was until his dying day.

A Mobster From The Beginning

Carmine John Persico Jr. was born in New York City on August 8, 1933. His father was a legal stenographer, a noble profession compared to what his son would become. Unlike many of his Mafia counterparts, Persico didn’t grow up in the mob but instead grew up on the streets, forming his own gangs and getting into fights.

After gaining a childhood reputation as a bully, Persico dropped out of school at 16, preferring to spend his days on the streets as opposed to inside a classroom. Around that same time, he formed a street gang known as the Garfield Boys. Within the next year, he would be accused of fatally beating a rival gang member in Prospect Park, though all charges would eventually be dropped.

Over the next few years with the Garfield Boys, Carmine Persico made a name for himself as a gangster not to be trifled with. Naturally, the Mafia became interested in the young man and in the early 1950s he was recruited by the Profaci crime family, which would later become the Colombo family.

For his first act as a Mafia man, the Profaci family threw him into the deep end. The details of the crime are mostly speculation, as the case remains unsolved, but rumor has it that Persico was responsible for the infamous 1957 death of Albert Anastasia.

Albert Anastasia Murder

Getty ImagesThe murder of Albert Anastasia.

No one was ever charged for the gruesome crime, but several Colombo family members, as well as Persico’s blood relatives, claimed Persico bragged about committing the crime in later years.

With the murder of such an important figure under his belt (assuming he was the killer), Carmine Persico became a respected figure in the Mafia and quickly began climbing the ranks of power.

Carmine “The Snake” Persico

Though the Profaci family had taken Carmine Persico under their wing, it soon became clear to him that Joe Profaci, head of the family, was not a satisfactory leader.

Before long, a faction of the Profaci family, led by the Gallo brothers Joe, Albert, and Lawrence began to conspire to overthrow Joe Profaci. The bosses of other crime families, allegedly also disappointed in Profaci’s leadership, began encouraging the Gallos. Carlo Gambino and Tommy Lucchese specifically supported the Gallos’ plan to overthrow Profaci.

Knowing that Persico was also on board, the Gallos invited him to discuss strategy. Profaci, however, had gotten word of the Gallos’ plan and bribed Persico with lucrative rackets if he’d switch sides against them. The night that Persico had been scheduled to meet the Gallos, he ambushed them, allegedly attempting to strangle Joe Gallo.

Though a policeman broke up the fight, causing Persico to flee, word got around that Persico had flipped sides. Before long, he earned himself his infamous nickname: “The Snake.”

Young Carmine Persico

Kagan, Gary/NY Daily News via Getty ImagesAssistant District Attorney Louis Andreozzi (left) talks to Carmine Persico Jr., 17, at Bergen St. Police Station. Persico was being held on a homicide charge.

In 1962, Joe Profaci died after a battle with cancer. He was succeeded by underboss Joseph Magliocco, who was forced out a year later by Joe Colombo.

During Magliocco’s reign, the Gallo brothers attempted to retaliate against Carmine Persico and almost succeeded. One night, a van pulled up next to Persico’s car and a gunman shot him in the shoulder, hand, and face. Rumor has it that Persico spat out the bullet that had hit him in the face and drove off.

After the attempt on his life, however, a different fate was in store for Carmine Persico. In 1963, he was arrested on extortion charges and imprisoned for a short time.

However, despite his imprisonment, when Joe Colombo took over the family, he made Persico a capo.

Carmine Persico: From Capo To Convict

After being released from prison, Carmine Persico returned to the streets full time, working time in labor racketeering, extortion, loan-sharking, hijacking, illegal gambling, and murder for hire. By the time 1970 rolled around, Persico’s crew was the Colombo family’s most profitable.

Unfortunately, his high profits caught the eye of the police and in 1971, Persico was sentenced back to prison, this time for eight years. However, while the bars held Persico in, they did nothing to stop his control of the family since being made boss in 1973. During his imprisonment, he ordered dozens of hits and was even successful in ordering the murder of longtime enemy Joe Gallo.

Joe Gallo

Jim Mooney/NY Daily News Archive via Getty ImagesJoe Gallo, also known as “Crazy Joe” waiting in a hearing room at Brooklyn Supreme Court.

In 1979, Persico was finally released from prison. However, his freedom was short-lived. By 1984, Persico and several Colombo family members were indicted for racketeering. After the indictment was announced, Persico went into hiding but unfortunately chose an inconvenient place to hide: an FBI informant’s house. He was arrested soon after his arrival.

In 1986, the trial that would end with Carmine Persico’s life imprisonment began. Persico chose to serve as his own lawyer, believing that his experience being sentenced to prison several times before gave him adequate experience on the subject.

Despite Judge John F. Keenan’s praise of Persico’s tactics during the trial – he described Persico as “one of the most intelligent people I have ever seen in my life” – Carmine Persico ultimately lost the case. In two separate sentencings, he was handed a 39-year sentence and a 100-year sentence to be served consecutively, both for various crimes associated with the Colombo family.

At the time of his sentencing, Carmine Persico was only 53 and had been running the Colombo family for 14 years, making him the youngest Mafia boss in New York.

Carmine Persico’s Life Behind Bars

Despite serving what is essentially a life sentence, Carmine Persico was never stripped of his title. Under Mafia rules, a boss keeps his title unless he dies or retires.

From behind bars, Persico continued to run the family. So loyal were his family members that when an underboss attempted to elect a new boss, he was overthrown in favor of the imprisoned Persico.

Though the organized crime syndicate as he knew it had all but dissolved, Carmine Persico remained boss, at least in name, until he died. Of course, there wasn’t much for him to do in the way of actual leadership, so he was forced to find alternative pastimes.

Over the course of his imprisonment, Persico spent time in three penitentiaries. He began his sentence in Illinois at the United States Penitentiary, where he continued his Mafia dealings. From there, he moved to the United States Penitentiary in Lompoc, California, where he formed an Italian Cultural Club for inmates, made friends with other ex-Mafia members like Patriarca family consigliere Joseph Russo and Lucchese family associate Anthony Senter, and played drums in a four-man band he formed with Russo.

Portrait Of Carmine Persico

Yvonne Hemsey/Getty ImagesCarmine Persico in 1986.

Finally, Persico was moved to his final destination, the medium-security Federal Correctional Complex in Butner, North Carolina. He had 31 years left until the possibility of release, and had he survived to the age of 117, the man also nicknamed “Immortal” could’ve seen the light of day again.

Carmine Persico’s Death In Prison

Carmine Persico died on Thursday, March 7, 2019. According to CNN, the mob boss passed away at Duke University Medical Center shortly after his 36th year behind bars.

“From my legal relationship with Carmine, he was a great client, a nice guy, and a wonderful man,” said his attorney, Benson Weintraub.

But it wasn’t just Persico’s attorney that saw such immense value and potential in the felon. Even Judge John F. Keenan, who sentenced him to a life in prison, was so impressed by the eloquent criminal who defended himself, that he had to express his frustration at the 1986 sentencing.

“You are a tragedy,” said Judge Keenan. “You are one of the most intelligent people I have seen in my life.”

Of course, to those busy ridding New York’s streets from the toxic, dangerous elements Persico embodied and represented, his eventual imprisonment was a sign of relief. Rudy Giuliani considered Persico’s capture as one of the most victorious moments of his time as US attorney in Manhattan.

Since Persico was still very much an acting mob boss, regardless of conviction by the law, he easily managed to order a hit against Giuliani in response. Of course, the current attorney to President Trump was able to evade the prospect of an assassination.

In the end, he spent his time regaling fellow inmates with tales from his past, learning new card games, and watching 60 Minutes with his good friend Bernie Madoff.

After this look at Carmine Persico, read about other notorious mafia bosses like Paul Castellano and John Franzese.

Katie Serena
A former staff writer at All That's Interesting, Katie Serena has also published work in Salon.
John Kuroski
John Kuroski is the editorial director of All That's Interesting. He graduated from New York University with a degree in history, earning a place in the Phi Alpha Theta honor society for history students. An editor at All That's Interesting since 2015, his areas of interest include modern history and true crime.
Citation copied
Cite This Article
Serena, Katie. "The Story Of Carmine Persico, The Feared Boss Of The Colombo Family.", May 4, 2024, Accessed May 22, 2024.