Robert Hansen was a well-liked baker and an avid hunter in Alaska. But no one knew that in his spare time, the “Butcher Baker” was hunting more than game.
In the 1924 short story The Most Dangerous Game, author Richard Connell recounts the tale of a wealthy Russian aristocrat who, bored with trapping animals, lures a big-game hunter to his island and hunts him for sport.
The plot underscores the moral ambiguity of hunting. But ever since the classic short story was published, the perverse idea of humans hunting humans has captivated people.
The disturbing concept has appeared time and again in the plots of novels, TV shows, and movies, but for the most part it has been relegated to the pages of fiction.
However in 1971, Robert Hansen, a.k.a the “Butcher Baker,” turned it into a horrifying, decade-long reality.
Who Was Robert Hansen, The “Butcher Baker” Of Alaska?
Unlike his fictional counterpart, Robert Hansen was no aristocratic nobleman. Born on February 15, 1939, in Estherville, Iowa, his father was a Danish immigrant who owned a bakery. He was also a strict disciplinarian.
Hansen’s childhood was not an easy one. He worked long hours in the family bakery from a young age. Though he was naturally left-handed he was forced to use his right hand instead, a switch that resulted in a lifelong stutter.
As a teenager he was painfully shy, had bad acne, and spoke with a stutter — an impediment that resulted in years of mockery. The boys at school made fun of him, and the girls he liked rejected him. He was often described as a loner.
As a social outcast, he took refuge in time spent alone and over time became an avid game hunter, channeling his rage and fantasies of vengeance into the sport of stalking animals.
An Insatiable Thirst For Revenge
In 1957, when he was 18 years old, Hansen joined the United States Army Reserve, hoping to leave behind the troubled person he’d been in his youth and make something of himself.
For a while, he did. After serving a year in the reserves, he became an assistant drill instructor in Pocahontas, Iowa and even married a young woman he met there.
But Hansen still felt mistreated by the community and sought retaliation. In 1960, at age 21, he convinced a young employee of the bakery to help him burn down a school bus garage. When the boy later confessed, Hansen was arrested. His wife divorced him, leaving him alone and incarcerated.
Though he was released just 20 months into his three-year sentence for arson, he was jailed a few more times afterward for petty theft. Still he managed to remarry, to another local woman.
Finally, Hansen decided he’d had enough of the contiguous United States. In 1967 he moved to Anchorage, Alaska, which was about as far from his life in Iowa as he could get. He moved into a small community, had two children with his wife, and settled into a quiet life. He was well liked and even opened up a small bakery.
But while the townspeople bought into the facade of the happy baker with a quiet family and a knack for hunting, inside Hansen was still the young man who had been endlessly mocked, repeatedly rejected by women, and was wrought with an insatiable thirst for revenge.
A Lucky Escape
In 1983, more than a decade after Hansen moved to Anchorage, a 17-year-old woman named Cindy Paulson was found running frantically down Sixth Avenue, barefoot and handcuffed.
After being picked up by a driver and returned to safety, Paulson, a prostitute, told her story to police. She described being held hostage by a man who’d handcuffed her to his car, held her at gunpoint, and took her to his house where he chained her by the neck.
The man raped and tortured her repeatedly, before attempting to load her onto a plane and take her to his cabin in the Matanuska-Susitna Valley about 35 miles north of Anchorage. As the man prepared the plane for takeoff, Paulson managed to escape.
Hansen fit the description of the kidnapper perfectly. Paulson even described his stutter and identified his plane. But police still brought him in reluctantly. After all, though he may have been a quiet man, the local baker was well liked in the community.
Hansen admitted that he had met the woman but claimed she was setting him up because he had refused to pay her extortion demands. When he told police about his strong alibi, provided by a friend, he was released.
The FBI Hits The Mark
Meanwhile, Alaska State Troopers were convinced a serial killer was on the loose. Several sex workers and dancers had gone missing, and the troopers were beginning to find bodies.
When two bodies were discovered in the Matanuska-Susitna Valley, along with .223 shell casings nearby, Hansen was a prime suspect. But the police needed proof.
This led to the involvement of the FBI, including now-retired FBI agent John Douglas, who helped pioneer the field of criminal profiling (and whose story is depicted in the Netflix series Mindhunter.)
Douglas put together a psychological profile of the killer based on the details of the case and the injuries inflicted on the recovered bodies. He theorized that the killer was an experienced hunter with low self-esteem and a history of being rejected by women — and that he likely had a stutter.
Though he had been cleared several times before, there was no doubt about it: Hansen fit the profile almost exactly. What’s more, he owned a bush plane and a cabin in the Matanuska-Susitna Valley.
The police soon obtained a warrant to search Hansen’s plane, car, and homes. What they found shocked them. The horror that Hansen’s victims had endured was almost too horrifying to believe.
How Robert Hansen Hunted Humans Like Prey
In Anchorage, Hansen was a respected business owner known for his skill as a bowhunter. The den in his home was decorated with hunting trophies and animals mounted on the walls, and he even set a few bowhunting records.
But what no one knew is that for more than a decade, the hunter had also been collecting “trophies” from another kind of kill.
Hansen mainly targeted sex workers and exotic dancers from around Anchorage. He would kidnap the women and either drive or fly his private bush plane out to his cabin in the remote Alaskan bush.
If the women didn’t put up a fight, he would rape them and bring them back to town, threatening them into secrecy. But those who did not cooperate suffered a truly nightmarish fate.
Out in the wilderness — his favorite location was along Knik River — Hansen would set the women free. For a moment they’d have hope that there was a chance to escape. Then, as they ran for their lives, he would track them down, taking his time, hunting them like wild animals.
Armed with a hunting knife and a .223-caliber Ruger Mini-14 rifle, he’d torture the women with this chase for hours or sometimes days at a time, until he located his prey and shot them like game.
The story of Hansen’s horrific 12-year killing spree later became the subject of the 2013 movie Frozen Ground starring John Cusack as Robert Hansen and Nicolas Cage as the Alaskan State Trooper investigating the murders.
“X” Marks The Spot
While searching Hansen’s home, police found an aviation map of the area hidden in the headboard of the bed. It was marked with tiny “X’s” denoting the kill and burial sites of his victims.
Some of the “X” marks matched up with where police had found bodies. There were 24 “X’s” in all.
What’s more, in his psychological profile of the killer Douglas had predicted that the murderer would keep souvenirs from his prey. And sure enough, in the basement of Hansen’s home police they found a stash of jewelry. In the stash was a necklace that belonged to one of the victims.
Faced with the evidence, Hansen confessed to murdering 17 women and raping another 30 women over a 12-year period.
Hansen was sentenced to 461 years plus life in prison without parole in 1984. He was imprisoned at Spring Creek Correctional Center in Seward, Alaska, where he died in 2014.
As part of a plea bargain, the “Butcher Baker” was only ever charged with four of the 17 murders he confessed to — and some believe he actually killed more than 20 women.
In exchange for the reduced conviction, Hansen agreed to assist police in locating the remaining bodies plotted on his kill map. Unfortunately, five of the bodies have still not been found to this day.
After learning about Robert Hansen, the Butcher Baker, read about Ed Gein, another horrifying murderer who got what was coming to him. Then, check out the big game hunter who was trampled by his prey.