Aniello Dellacroce: The Bone-Chilling Gambino Underboss Who Mentored John Gotti

Published October 29, 2023
Updated June 7, 2024

While John Gotti was the "Teflon Don," he may not have been godfather at all if not for Aniello Dellacroce.

Aniello Dellacroce

Hal Mathewson/NY Daily News Archive via Getty ImagesAniello Dellacroce (right) leaves a hearing on February 12, 1970.

Even to other gangsters and detectives who’d been hardened by living with the Mafia for decades, Gambino family underboss Aniello Dellacroce was a fearsome figure.

In the words of New York detective Joseph Coffey, “Dellacroce was one of the scariest individuals I’ve ever met in my life. Dellacroce’s eyes were, like, he didn’t have any eyes. Did you ever see Children of the Damned? His eyes were so blue that they weren’t even there. It was like looking right through him.”

One federal prosecutor agreed, saying, “He likes to peer into a victim’s face, like some kind of dark angel, at the moment of death.”

And before Aniello Dellacroce died of cancer at age 71 in 1985, nobody knows for sure how many people he killed. What we do know is that he was one of the most terrifying figures that the Mafia ever produced, as well as the mentor to John Gotti.

This is the blood-soaked story of Aniello Dellacroce.

Aniello Dellacroce’s Introduction To The Mafia

Aniello Dellacroce was born in 1914, the son of Italian immigrants in New York who grew up in Little Italy. He took to petty crime at a young age and, like many first-generation Italian-Americans at the time, found himself drawn into the world of the Mafia.

Dellacroce first studied the craft of organized crime under New York gangster Albert Anastasia, the self-proclaimed “Executioner.” Dellacroce followed him into the Vincent Mangano crime family, which later became the infamous Gambino family.

During the early years of his career, Dellacroce built up a reputation as a clever and extremely brutal gangster. He used to dress as a priest to avoid attention, call himself “Father O’Neil,” and cheerfully greeted policemen on their beats. He showed little fear of the law, and in fact enjoyed taunting officers. On one occasion, Dellacroce found two policemen taping him and reportedly forced the officers to eat the tape at gunpoint.

And he also used his gun to execute brutal murders that made use of his chilling gaze. “He likes to peer into a victim’s face, like some kind of dark angel, at the moment of death,” said one federal prosecutor. “His eyes had no color…as if his soul was transparent,” one reporter said. “Dellacroce was one of the scariest individuals I’ve ever met in my life,” said one mob investigator. “Dellacroce’s eyes were, like, he didn’t have any eyes. Did you ever see Children of the Damned? His eyes were so blue that they weren’t even there. It was like looking right through him.”

In 1957, Aniello Dellacroce’s mentor Albert Anastasia was murdered by gunmen while sitting in a barbershop. According to some, the hit was organized by Carlo Gambino, another mafioso who wanted to become the next godfather of the family.

Albert Anastasia's Murder

George Silk/The LIFE Picture Collection/Getty ImagesDetectives take notes and examine the barbershop of New York’s Park Sheraton Hotel, where the body of Albert Anastasia lies partially covered on the floor after his murder by unknown gunmen on Oct. 25, 1957.

In spite of the loyalty he felt to Anastasia and the rumors surrounding his death, Aniello Dellacroce believed that the family always came first. And he pledged himself to Gambino as he took over the family.

Life In The Gambino Family

Aniello Dellacroce served for decades as the underboss to the new Gambino family. That life treated him well as he earned a healthy income from illegal gambling and racketeering. Dellacroce continued to show cleverness as underboss. He recruited look-alikes to lead the police on chases across town as he quietly ran his operation in the shadows.

As Gambino aged and his health declined, he had to consider who might replace him as head of the family. Most of the family’s associates considered Dellacroce the rightful heir, but Gambino instead nominated his brother-in-law, Paul Castellano.

Paul Castellano

Bettmann/Getty ImagesGambino boss Paul Castellano on February 26, 1985, after he posted a $2 million bail following an indictment on racketeering charges.

Loyal as ever, Dellacroce accepted the decision.

Gambino’s death was an impetus for Aniello Dellacroce to consider his own heir. He eventually settled on a young man named John Gotti, who had long been an associate with the Gambino family.

Dellacroce filled Gotti’s head with tales of life in the old Mafia under Anastasia. Moved by Dellacroce’s stories, Gotti officially joined his crew as a capo shortly after his release from prison for highjacking. He would quickly raise his stock in the Gambino family through successful hits and other lucrative schemes.

Aniello Dellacroce And John Gotti Align Against Paul Castellano

When Paul Castellano officially took control of the Gambino family, he recognized Aniello Dellacroce’s service by giving him control a significant number of the family’s crews. In doing this, Castellano inadvertently created a competing faction within his family of those most loyal to Dellacroce. There were now essentially two families within the Gambino organization, with Dellacroce at one helm and Castellano at the other.

Bergin Hunt And Fish Club

Daily NewsJohn Gotti and other members of the Gambino family, photographed by FBI surveillance outside of the Bergin Hunt and Fish Club in Ozone Park, Queens.

Gotti quickly became the number two man in the Dellacroce faction, but tensions only rose between himself and Dellacroce.

Castellano had ordered that no one in his family would deal in drugs. Dellacroce agreed with this caveat and warned his crew that if he found out any of them were dealing, he would kill them himself. Of course, by this time Gotti was heavily involved in drug trafficking.

One of Gotti’s associates was eventually arrested for heroin dealing. Castellano’s suspicion immediately fell upon Gotti himself, and also his close friend Angelo Ruggiero.

At first, Aniello Dellacroce went out of his way to protect Gotti and Ruggiero from Castellano. When tapes from prosecutors revealed Ruggiero had been insulting Castellano, Dellacroce refused to turn the tapes over to the Gambino family head, knowing that Castellano would kill Ruggiero.

Dellacroce seemed also to have shared some of Ruggiero’s distaste for Castellano. In spite of his own sinister warnings earlier, Dellacroce truly did not want to kill Ruggiero and Gotti. But he also did not want to start a war. His mediation kept the Gambino family from dissolving into civil war and Castellano from murdering his crew members.

“I’ve been tryin’ to take your part with these tapes from the very, very beginning… Then all we gotta do then, we go and roll it up and go to war,” Dellacroce told Ruggiero on one of the tapes.

But for Gotti, the case of the tapes was even more detrimental. He was recorded insulting Dellacroce for some of his decisions. “I told him, ‘Neil is not going to like this,'” a detective said to Gotti upon the prosecution, “and it was the only time I’ve ever seen him look remorseful.” It is evident from this fact that despite his gossip, Gotti had some real respect for Dellacroce.

In turn, Dellacroce respected Gotti’s potential. He continually pushed the idea that Gotti should eventually take over control of his crews. For obvious reasons, Castellano didn’t share his enthusiasm for Gotti.

Aniello Dellacroce Casket

John Pedin/NY Daily News Archive via Getty ImagesCasket containing the body of Aniello Dellacroce carried from Old St. Patrick’s Church on Mott St. after his funeral on December 4, 1985.

During this time, Dellacroce’s health failed as he had been diagnosed with terminal brain cancer. He died from the disease in 1985. With Aniello Dellacroce’s death, the fragile balance that kept violence in check within the Gambino family was shattered.

Dellacroce’s Legacy And Gambino Family Turmoil

Paul Gotti and Angelo Ruggiero moved quickly against Castellano shortly after Aniello Dellacroce’s death. Castellano was gunned down outside a Manhattan restaurant and Gotti could subsequently take complete control of the Gambino family.

Paul Castellano Corpse

Getty ImagesPolice removed the blood-covered body of reputed Boss of Bosses, Paul C. ‘Big Paul’ Castellano, from the crime scene after he and his driver were gunned down outside Sparks Steak House by three gunmen who fled on foot. Dec. 16, 1985.

Gotti would rule the Gambino family until 1992 when he was convicted for a number of murder and racketeering charges and sentenced to life in prison. He would die just a few years later of cancer.

It may have been Dellacroce’s influence that made Gotti such an unusual figure in modern organized crime. Gotti often seemed like a figure from another era, and with a mentor like Aniello Dellacroce, it’s not hard to imagine why. With Dellacroce’s death and Gotti’s conviction, that era of the Mafia seemed to have finally drawn to a close.

After this look at Aniello Dellacroce, read 27 John Gotti facts you may not have known. Then, check out these grisly photos of the 1980s mafia.

Wyatt Redd
A graduate of Belmont University with a Bachelor's in History and American University with a Master's in journalism, Wyatt Redd is a writer from Nashville, Tennessee who has worked with VOA and global news agency AFP.
Cara Johnson
A writer and editor based in Charleston, South Carolina and an assistant editor at All That's Interesting, Cara Johnson holds a B.A. in English and Creative Writing from Washington & Lee University and an M.A. in English from College of Charleston and has written for various publications in her six-year career.
Citation copied
Cite This Article
Redd, Wyatt. "Aniello Dellacroce: The Bone-Chilling Gambino Underboss Who Mentored John Gotti.", October 29, 2023, Accessed June 16, 2024.