The 19th century was a golden age for hoaxes in America. So when two men found a 10-foot "giant" buried on a New York farm, few people questioned the discovery.
The 19th century was a golden age for hoaxes. So when two men found a 10-foot-tall giant buried in Cardiff, New York, thousands of people paid to see it. As headlines reported the discovery, only a small number of dissenters questioned the petrified giant theory.
This is the story of the Cardiff giant hoax.
The Cardiff Giant Creates A Firestorm Of Attention
While digging a well on Octoctober 16, 1869, two laborers discovered something unusual – a massive stone foot buried three feet underground. When Gideon Emmons and Henry Nichols continued digging, they uncovered what appeared to be a giant. “I declare, some old Indian has been buried here!” one of them supposedly proclaimed.
William Newell, the owner of the property where the giant had been found, quickly declared it a major discovery. He set up a tent around the giant and began charging visitors 25 cents to see the marvel. Within two days, Newell had raised the price to 50 cents. And business was booming.
The discovery, soon dubbed the Cardiff Giant, drew visitors from miles around. “Men left their work,” the Syracuse Journal later reported. “Women caught up their babies, and children in numbers, all hurried to the scene.”
Cornell University’s first president, Andrew White, even made the journey. “The roads were crowded with buggies, carriages, and even omnibuses from the city,” White recalled. “And with lumber-wagons from the farms — all laden with passengers.”
Thousands Flocked To See The Petrified Giant
When visitors arrived at Cardiff, they were ushered into Newell’s tent. There, they came face to face with the giant.
“Lying in its grave,” White described, “with the subdued light from the roof of the tent falling upon it, and with the limbs contorted as if in a death struggle, it produced a most weird effect. An air of great solemnity pervaded the place. Visitors hardly spoke above a whisper.”
Newspapers lauded the find. The Syracuse Daily Standard called the Cardiff Giant “A NEW WONDER,” while another paper declared it “a singular discovery.”
In the first week alone after the Cardiff Giant was discovered, about 2,500 people flocked to see the marvel.
Visitors Debated The Origins Of The Cardiff Giant
What, exactly, was the Cardiff Giant? In 1869, many believed it was a petrified ancient man. After all, Cardiff boasted numerous fossils, so the Cardiff Giant was thought to have been a Biblical giant preserved eons earlier.
According to one Syracuse pastor, the Cardiff Giant offered Biblical proof: “Is it not strange that any human being, after seeing this wonderfully preserved figure, can deny the evidence of his senses,” the pastor wondered, “And refuse to believe, what is so evidently the fact, that we have here a fossilized human being, perhaps one of the giants mentioned in Scripture?”
Cornell University’s president said that believers in the Biblical giant theory acted “in spite of all scientific reasons to the contrary.”
Meanwhile, a science lecturer from Syracuse put forth a different theory: French Jesuits carved the statue centuries earlier. The statue theory drew support from New York State Geologist James Hall, who called the stone giant “the most remarkable object yet brought to light in our country.”
As the debate raged, William Newell threw up his hands and suggested re-burying the giant at one point. But his neighbors reportedly stopped him, arguing the Cardiff Giant had historical value. Not long after, Newell jumped on an offer from businessmen of $30,000 for a three-fourths stake.
The Cardiff Giant Was A Hoax – And Newell Was In On It From The Beginning
As it turned out, the Cardiff Giant was a hoax all along. William Newell’s relative George Hull created the statue during the 1860s after a heated argument with a Methodist preacher who insisted on a literal interpretation of the Bible. Even when it came to verse Genesis 6:4 – “there were giants in the earth in those days” – the preacher held his ground.
After the argument, Hull said, “Suddenly, I thought of making a stone giant, and passing it off as a petrified man.”
Hull’s hoax actually began in Iowa. He bought a huge block of gypsum under the cover story that it would become an Abraham Lincoln monument. Hull shipped the block to Chicago, where a German stone cutter carved it.
The rails took the giant from Chicago to upstate New York, where Hull and Newell buried it in November 1868.
Nearly one year later, Newell ordered two laborers to dig a well exactly where the Cardiff Giant lay buried. Within weeks, Newell and Hull were able to cash in on what was a small fortune at the time.
George Hull Created The Hoax To Criticize Religious Beliefs
The Cardiff Giant hoax wasn’t just about getting rich quick. Hull also wanted to prove a point about science and faith. If people fell for the hoax, it would prove their gullibility and undermine a literal interpretation of the Bible.
As an atheist in the 19th century, Hull was part of a minority and felt like a social outcast. So he wanted the hoax to transform his critics into fools.
Hull became so obsessed with the hoax that he spent nearly $3,000 creating the phony giant. However, the investment paid off when a group of businessmen forked over $30,000 for a stake.
The Hoax Triggered A Lawsuit When P.T. Barnum Created A Replica
When showman P.T. Barnum offered to buy the Cardiff Giant for $50,000 and was turned down, he hired a sculptor to fashion a replica. Outside of Barnum’s Manhattan museum, ads blared: “What is it? Is it a Statue? Is it a Petrification? Is it a Stupendous Fraud?”
Barnum’s giant wasn’t the only copy of the Cardiff Giant. Within months, replicas popped up across the country.
In response, the syndicate sought an injunction against Barnum. But the judge responded, “Bring your giant here, and if he swears to his own genuineness as a bona fide petrifaction, you shall have the injunction you ask for.”
Soon news of the hoax went public. The mason who carved the giant apparently confessed to the Chicago Tribune, and a respected paleontologist denounced the giant as “a most decided humbug.”
The Philadelphia Inquirer summed up the wave of petrified giants sweeping the country: “It is rather rich that we should be victimized by such a fraud upon a fraud.”
Yet even after the hoax was exposed, some still wanted to see the Cardiff Giant. The statue was showcased at the 1901 Pan-American Exposition and was later sold to a publisher in Iowa.
In 1947, the Cardiff Giant returned to New York, where viewers can still visit it today at the Cooperstown Farmers’ Museum.