The Twisted Tale Of Dean Corll, The ‘Candy Man’ Killer Who Terrorized Houston

Published February 17, 2018
Updated February 10, 2021

Between 1970 and 1973, serial killer Dean Corll raped and murdered at least 28 boys and young men — with the help of two teenage accomplices.

Dean Corll

YouTubeDean Corll pretended to be an ordinary electrician — but he was actually the infamous “Candy Man” killer.

To everyone in his Houston neighborhood, Dean Corll seemed like a decent, ordinary man. He was known for spending most of his time at the small candy factory that his mother owned, and he got along well with many of the neighborhood kids. He even gave free candy to local school children, which earned him the nickname “Candy Man.”

But behind his sweet smile, Dean Corll had a dark secret: He was a serial killer who murdered at least 28 boys and young men in the early 1970s. This horrific killing spree would later be dubbed the “Houston Mass Murders.” And it wasn’t until Corll himself was killed in 1973 that the truth came to light.

And shockingly, the person who murdered Corll was his own accomplice — a teenage boy whom he had groomed to help him with his murder spree.

The Early Life Of Dean Corll

The Candy Man Killer

YouTubeDean Corll in 1973, months before he was shot to death by his 17-year-old accomplice, Elmer Wayne Henley.

It’s a standard trope in true-crime lore that a serial killer’s depravity can be traced back to some kind of horrific childhood event. But based on what’s known about Corll’s early life, it’s tough to imagine that anyone could’ve ever predicted that he’d become a murderer.

Born in 1939, in Fort Wayne, Indiana, Dean Corll did observe at least some family troubles early on in life. His parents reportedly never had a happy marriage, and they would often argue. But as far as anyone can tell, there was nothing especially unusual about these fights.

Corll’s father was also known to be a strict disciplinarian. But it’s unknown if this ever led to abuse — or punishments that were worse than those typical for the 1940s. Meanwhile, Corll’s mother was known for doting on him.

His parents first divorced in 1946 and briefly reconciled afterward, getting married once again. But after they got divorced a second time, his mother decided to spend some time traveling around the South. She eventually remarried a traveling salesman, and the family settled in Vidor, Texas.

In school, Corll was a well-behaved, if solitary, young man. His grades were decent enough to escape notice either for good or for ill, and he occasionally dated girls from the neighborhood or from school.

So how did this seemingly normal American boy of the 1950s become the “Candy Man” serial killer of the 1970s? Eerily, the nexus between these two stories appears to be his mother’s candy shop.

How Dean Corll Became The “Candy Man”

Candy Man Serial Killer

Wikimedia CommonsDean Corll briefly served in the U.S. Army from 1964 to 1965.

In the mid-1950s, Dean Corll’s mother and stepfather started a candy company called Pecan Prince, initially working from the family garage. From the very start, Corll played a crucial role in the company.

While his stepfather sold the candy on his sales route and his mother managed the actual business, Corll and his younger brother operated the machines that produced the candy.

By the time his mother divorced her second husband, Corll had spent several years working at the candy shop. At some point, Corll briefly returned to Indiana to care for his widowed grandmother. But by 1962, he was ready to come back to Texas and help his mother with a new venture.

Now called the Corll Candy Company, Corll’s mother started this revamped business in the Houston Heights area. Unsurprisingly, she named Dean Corll the vice president and his younger brother the secretary-treasurer.

Although Corll was drafted into the U.S. Army in 1964 and served for about 10 months, he successfully applied for a hardship discharge after explaining that he needed to help his mother at her store. And so for several more years, Corll continued to work at the candy company — presumably bringing joy to his customers.

Elmer Wayne Henley

YouTubeDean Corll with Elmer Wayne Henley, his 17-year-old accomplice in several murders, in 1973.

However, Corll’s involvement at the company was not as wholesome as it seemed. There were warning signs that he was interested in underage boys.

For instance, one young teenage boy who worked at the company complained to Corll’s mother that Corll had made sexual advances toward him. But rather than questioning Corll, his mother simply fired the boy.

Meanwhile, the candy factory itself seemed to attract several teenage boys — both as employees and as customers. Some of them were runaways or troubled youths. Dean Corll quickly built up a rapport with these teens.

In the back of the factory, Corll even installed a pool table where company employees and their friends — many of whom were teenage boys — could congregate throughout the day. Corll was said to be openly flirtatious and befriended many of them.

Among them was 12-year-old David Brooks, who, like many children, was first introduced to Corll with offers of candy and a place to hang out.

Over a period of two years, Corll groomed Brooks and steadily built his trust. By the time Brooks was 14, Corll was regularly sexually abusing the boy — and bribing him with gifts and money for his silence.

The Heinous Crimes Of The “Candy Man” Killer

Jeffrey Konen

YouTubeJeffrey Konen was the earliest known victim of the “Candy Man” killer. He was murdered in 1970.

In September 1970, Dean Corll killed his first known victim. By this point, his mother had divorced a third husband and moved to Colorado. But Corll stayed behind in Houston since he had found a new job as an electrician.

Corll also moved into a new apartment — where he would begin to commit horrific crimes in his early 30s. But he wouldn’t stay there for long. During the Houston Mass Murders, he would frequently move between apartments and rent houses, sometimes staying in one spot for just a few weeks.

His first recorded victim was Jeffrey Konen, an 18-year-old student who was hitchhiking from Austin to Houston. Konen was believed to have been looking for a way to get to his girlfriend’s house, and Corll likely picked him up with an offer of a ride.

Just a few months later in December, Corll abducted two more teenage boys and tied them to his bed in his home. He was in the process of sexually assaulting them when suddenly Brooks walked in on him. Corll initially told Brooks that he was part of a gay pornography ring and had sent the teens out to California. But later, he confessed to Brooks that he had killed them.

To buy Brooks’ silence, Corll bought him a Corvette. He also offered Brooks $200 for any boy he could bring to him. And Brooks apparently agreed.

Elmer Wayne Henley still insists that he is not a serial killer, despite his six murder convictions.

One of the boys Brooks brought to Corll was Elmer Wayne Henley. But for some reason, Corll decided not to kill him. Instead, he groomed Henley to participate in his sickening scheme just like he did for Brooks, feeding him the same story about the “porn ring” before telling him the truth and offering him cash as a reward for his help in finding victims.

Henley later said, “Dean told me he would pay me $200 for every boy I could bring in and maybe more if they were really good looking boys.” In reality, Corll usually paid the boys just $5 or $10.

Henley has insisted that he initially refused the offer, but his family’s financial hardship led him to accept it. But even when he was paid far less than he’d hoped, he didn’t back out. Eerily, he seemed almost flattered to be included.

Together, in the early 1970s, Brooks and Henley would help the “Candy Man” killer by luring boys and young men, ranging in age from 13 to 20. The three used Corll’s Plymouth GTX muscle car or his white van to convince the boys to come with them, using candy, alcohol, or drugs to get them inside.

Dean Corll and his accomplices would take the boys to his home, where they bound and gagged the victims. Horrifically, Corll also forced them to write postcards to their families to say they were okay.

Each victim would often be tied to a wooden “torture board,” whereupon the three would rape him. Afterward, some victims were strangled to death and others were shot. Every boy brought back to Corll was murdered — with Brooks and Henley actively participating in the crimes.

Brooks would later describe Henley as being “especially sadistic.”

Desperate Parents Get Little Help From Police

A look back at the Houston Mass Murders in some harrowing footage from 1973.

One of Corll’s victims, Mark Scott, was 17 years old when he disappeared on April 20, 1972. His frantic parents quickly reported him missing after calling classmates, friends, and neighbors to see if they knew anything.

A few days later, the Scott family received a postcard purportedly from Mark saying that he’d found a job in Austin that paid $3 per hour and that all was well.

The Scotts did not believe that their boy would suddenly leave town without saying goodbye. They knew that something was terribly wrong. But like many family members of Corll’s victims, they received little help from the Houston Police Department when their sons went missing.

“I camped on that police department door for eight months,” a grieving father named Everett Waldrop told reporters, recalling when his sons first went missing. “But all they did was say, ‘Why are you down here? You know your boys are runaways.'”

Tragically, both of his sons, 15-year-old Donald and 13-year-old Jerry, were killed by Corll.

In Texas in the early 1970s, it wasn’t illegal for a child to run away from home, so the chief of the Houston Police Department claimed that there was nothing authorities could do to help them.

That chief was voted out of office in the first election held after Corll’s murders became known to the public.

The Violent End Of The “Candy Man” Killer

An Associated Press video from August 10, 1973, covering the discovery of the bodies of Dean Corll’s victims.

After nearly three years and 28 known murders, Corll turned on Henley on August 8, 1973. On that day, Henley had lured two teens — Tim Kerley and Rhonda Williams — to Corll’s home.

Williams was the only girl known to have been targeted during the murder spree, but Henley later insisted that he wasn’t planning on attacking her or Kerley. Instead, they were supposedly all there just to party.

From drinking heavily to huffing paint to get high, they all fell asleep earlier than expected. When Henley woke up, he discovered that he was tied up alongside Kerley and Williams. And Corll was screaming at Henley while waving his .22-caliber pistol: “I’m going to kill you, but first I’ll have my fun.”

Corll then carried Henley into the kitchen to let him know just how furious he was that he had brought a girl over to his home. Henley pleaded with Corll to untie him, saying that the two of them could kill both Williams and Kerley together. Eventually, Corll did untie Henley, and brought Kerley and Williams into the bedroom to be tied up to the “torture board.”

In doing so, Corll needed to put his gun down.

Williams, who survived the attack and only spoke publicly about it in 2013, recalled how Corll’s behavior had visibly shaken something in Henley’s mind.

“He stood at my feet, and just all of a sudden told Dean this couldn’t keep going on, he couldn’t let him keep killing his friends and that it had to stop,” she recalled. “Dean looked up and he was surprised. So he started getting up and he was like, ‘You’re not going to do anything to me.'”

Then, without another word, Henley shot Corll six times with the gun, killing him. And with that, the Houston Mass Murders finally came to an end.

The Aftermath Of The Houston Mass Murders

Lake Sam Rayburn

Wikimedia Commons Lake Sam Rayburn, a location where some of Corll’s victims were buried.

After killing Corll, Henley quickly called the police to confess what he’d done. He and Brooks soon made official confessions stating their involvement in the crimes and offered to show police where the victims were buried. (However, Brooks denied actively participating in the murders.)

Within a week, investigators recovered 17 bodies from makeshift graves and a boathouse shed. Soon after that, another 10 bodies were found on High Island Beach and in the woods near Lake Sam Rayburn.

Police didn’t find the remains of the 28th victim until 1983. And unfortunately, there’s no telling how many others Corll might have killed that Henley and Brooks didn’t know about.

Ultimately, Henley was convicted of six murders and sentenced to six life sentences. Brooks was convicted of one murder and received a life sentence as well. Since then, both men have been described as serial killers for their involvement in the Houston Mass Murders.

Elmer Wayne Henley And Robert Aramayo

Bettmann/Getty Images (l.) / Netflix (r.)Elmer Wayne Henley (left) leaving a Texas courthouse in 1973, and Robert Aramayo (right) playing Elmer Wayne Henley in the Netflix crime drama Mindhunter.

In the decades since, Henley has remained a controversial figure. From creating his own Facebook page to promoting his artwork from prison, he has drawn outrage from many who are furious at him for his role — and active participation — as a murder accomplice.

He has also spoken out in a number of shocking interviews, one in which he said, “My only regret is that Dean isn’t here now, so I could tell him what a good job I did killing him.”

Elmer Wayne Henley has also been featured in the second season of Netflix’s serial killer crime drama Mindhunter. He was portrayed by actor Robert Aramayo from HBO’s Game of Thrones.

As for Brooks, he lived a far quieter life behind bars. He regularly refused interviews and he chose not to correspond much with Henley — even when given the opportunity. Brooks died in prison in 2020 of COVID-19.

As for Dean Corll, very little else is known about him and much of his life remains a mystery. But after his death, those who knew him would have every reason in the world to want to forget that they ever did.

After this look at Dean Corll, the “Candy Man” killer, read up on the horrific story of serial killer Ed Kemper. Then, discover how some of history’s most infamous serial killers finally met their end.

William DeLong
William DeLong is a freelance wordsmith. He thanks you for reading his content.