The Case Of The Greenbrier Ghost, The Spirit That May Have Solved Her Own Murder

Published September 1, 2022
Updated November 7, 2023

Zona Heaster Shue's husband Erasmus snapped her neck in 1897 — then she allegedly returned from the dead as the “Greenbrier Ghost” to make sure he paid for his crime.

How could a young, healthy woman drop dead of an “everlasting faint”?

This question was one of the things keeping Mary Jane Heaster, of Greenbrier County, West Virginia, from a restful sleep in the winter of 1897, following the late January death of her newlywed daughter, Zona Heaster Shue.

Greenbrier Ghost

The Man Who Wanted Seven WivesAn unverified photo of Zona and Trout Shue, widely circulated as the only extant photo of the pair.

A healthy person doesn’t just drop dead of a heart attack — or an “everlasting faint,” as the examining doctor had written on his report. And to make matters worse, some contemporaneous reports even listed her cause of death as childbirth, despite no evidence pointing to Zona being pregnant at the time.

And so Mary Jane slept fitfully that winter. Then the ghostly visitations started.

Zona Heaster Shue’s spirit, now known as the “Greenbrier Ghost,” crept right up to her mother’s bedside and begged to climb in, Mary Jane reported. Zona was cold and she had something to tell her mother: It wasn’t a faint that had claimed her life — it was cold-blooded murder.

What unfolded next is the only documented case of a murderer convicted by the testimony of a ghost.

The Strange Death Of Zona Heaster Shue

Zona Heaster was 23 years old in October 1896 when she ran an errand in town and met 37-year-old blacksmith Erasmus “Trout” Shue. The pair married weeks later, despite Mary Jane’s objections, and settled into a house near Shue’s own blacksmith shop.

Three months later, on January 23, Zona was dead, found lifeless at the foot of the stairs by Andy Jones, a neighbor boy hired to do chores.

Andy ran to the blacksmith shop while his mother called Dr. George Knapp. Shue was there to meet Knapp, who arrived to find Zona had been taken to her bedroom and was already dressed for burial in a high-necked dress. Knapp began to examine the dead woman, and all the while, Shue began acting suspiciously.

Shue cried the whole time, but as soon as Knapp tried to examine Zona’s neck area, he got upset, so the doctor didn’t push the issue any further.

Meanwhile, there were rumors including local folks saying that Zona had given birth to an illegitimate child, and that Trout had been married twice before. His first marriage produced a child, Girta, and ended in divorce in 1889. His second wife, Lucy, died under mysterious circumstances. Some said she was pregnant and fell through ice, while others claimed it was a brick to the head, or poison, that did the unfortunate woman in.

What The Greenbrier Ghost Told Mary Jane Heaster

Mary Jane Heaster had never liked Erasmus Shue, and now her dead daughter, she claimed, was visiting her as a ghost and telling her that she’d been right all along about the man — and that he had, in fact, killed her daughter.

Zona Heaster Shue’s ghostly nighttime visits continued. Four nights in a row she came, Mary Jane claimed, filling her mother in on the discord that marked her brief marriage.

The day she died, Zona’s ghost allegedly said, her husband was angry with her because she had not fixed meat with his supper. He then brutally attacked her, capping off a marriage rife with abuse, struck her, and broke her neck.

Mary Jane woke up with a mission and headed straight to the office of Prosecutor John Alfred Preston, who agreed to make inquiries. He spoke with Dr. Knapp, who admitted to a not-so-thorough examination, and revealed that he had indeed noticed some bruises on Zona’s neck.

At the same time, townspeople told Preston about Shue’s odd behavior at the wake: He wouldn’t let anyone close to the coffin and he (or someone else) had placed a pillow on one side of her head.

Considering all of this, Preston had enough to order an exhumation of Zona’s body. There was a complete autopsy this time, and sure enough, Zona’s neck had been broken, dislocated between the first and second vertebrae. Her windpipe was crushed; she had been strangled.

The Greenbrier Ghost Becomes A Key Witness

Erasmus Shue was arrested and the subsequent trial lasted eight days. On the sixth day, he took the stand in his own defense and it did not end well. He rambled and said everyone was out to get him.

The jury deliberated for a little over an hour and returned a guilty verdict. Shue was sentenced to life behind bars and sent to the state prison in Moundsville after surviving a failed lynching. And, while the judge reportedly urged the jury to ignore the moe supernatural elements of the case against Shue, the stories were out in the open — and to this day, Zona Heaster Shue’s ghost is generally recognized as the reason her husband was convicted.

Today, a historical marker sits along Route 60 and reminds all who traverse the winding mountain roads that the Greenbrier Ghost helped convict her own killer.

After learning about the Greenbrier Ghost, read five celebrity ghost stories that will chill you to the bone. Then, check out 11 infamously haunted sites around the world.

Erik Hawkins
Erik Hawkins studied English and film at Keene State College in NH and has taught English as a Second Language stateside and in South America. He has done award-winning work as a reporter and editor on crime, local government, and national politics for almost 10 years, and most recently produced true crime content for NBC's Oxygen network.
John Kuroski
John Kuroski is the editorial director of All That's Interesting. He graduated from New York University with a degree in history, earning a place in the Phi Alpha Theta honor society for history students. An editor at All That's Interesting since 2015, his areas of interest include modern history and true crime.