The Contentious History Of The “Happy Birthday” Song

Published June 27, 2016

Up until this year, you were legally bound to pay one of the biggest media companies in the world a fee if you sang “Happy Birthday” in public. Here’s the backstory.


Getty Images/Court Records/ATI Composite

It’s bigger than the Beatles, Bach, and Beethoven. It’s beloved by children, often reviled by adults, and has been translated into nearly 20 languages. So just what is the omnipresent, divisive item in question?

The “Happy Birthday” song. And despite its ubiquity, its owners have been able to charge royalties for those who sing it for decades.

That’s right: up until this year, “Happy Birthday” was not part of the public domain, but instead a copyrighted moneymaker for its owners at Warner Bros. So just how did the English language’s most recognized song become so well known — and such a hotly-contested legal entity?

“Happy Birthday”’s Birth


The Kentucky cabin where the Hill sisters are said to have written “Happy Birthday.”

As with most folk music, it’s hard to point to the song’s definitive origins. Many accounts have Louisville, Kentucky sisters Patty and Mildred Hill down as the song’s original authors — or at least the authors of the song which led to “Happy Birthday” — which they wrote at the tail end of the 19th century.

According to the sisters, they penned the “Happy Birthday” melody in the 1890s for Patty’s kindergarten students. At first, it was called “Good Morning to All,” and sung each morning in class. When a student’s birthday arrived, the class would replace the “Good Morning to All” lyrics with “Happy Birthday to You,” Patty said in a later deposition.

As the song’s popularity expanded, the Hill sisters began to file suits against its unlicensed use — even against composers and playwrights Irving Berlin and Moss Hart, who allegedly used the song in a Broadway musical, The Band Wagon. Still, the sisters never copyrighted “Happy Birthday” (although they did copyright “Good Morning to All”) with Patty saying that she “[was] never a money grubber.”

All That's Interesting
A New York-based publisher established in 2010, All That's Interesting brings together subject-level experts in history, true crime, and science to share stories that illuminate our world.