Though the mansion didn’t look inviting in the least, it’s unlikely that any of the victims were dragged into its depths. They entered on their own volition, likely enchanted by the owner’s flattery and apparent affluence.
Often they were his employees. During his two short years in the castle, Holmes hired more than 150 women to work as his stenographers. A few of those were known to be his mistresses as well. Most of them came from wealthy families and some of them never saw those families again.
Holmes sometimes photographed his favorites. They were young, beautiful, and trusting of this gentleman in the big and unfamiliar city.
Despite the well-connected women who went missing under his employment, suspicions of murder weren’t what eventually led to Holmes’ demise. Rather, theft and financial schemes gone wrong caused his arrest in Boston on November 17, 1894.
After decades of criminal activity (the scale and complexity of which you really need a book to fully grasp), H.H. Holmes was behind bars.
While in jail, connections between him and at least one murder were revealed and a pile of financial charges were obscured by the more sinister accusations.
Though he boasted of committing at least 27 murders, he gave three different confessions while imprisoned — all with contradicting numbers.
The true amount of victims was impossible to corroborate because the mansion was specially equipped for Holmes to disintegrate leftover body parts in acid baths or to burn them in a human-sized stove. (In one pile of ashes, investigators found a small gold chain from a woman’s shoe.)
Noting the thousands of people who went missing during the World’s Fair, some papers suggested the actual count of Holmes’ victims stretched into the 200s.
“I was born with the devil in me,” Holmes would later explain. “I could not help the fact that I was a murderer, no more than the poet can help the inspiration to sing.”
For the most part, Holmes represented himself at his trial — displaying his classic grace and a “remarkable familiarity with the law,” according to one paper of the time.
His charm wasn’t enough for the jurors, though, and he was unanimously sentenced to hanging.
Very familiar with what could be done to a body after death, Holmes requested that his be encased in cement within his coffin.
Before his death in 1896, H.H. Holmes had suggested that he was turning into the devil. Even his face, he said, was taking on a demonic look.
Indeed, when the floor was dropped beneath him, his neck didn’t snap like it was supposed to. He lay twitching for 20 minutes before being pronounced dead.
Later, strange fates befell the people connected to the case.
The man who had initially tipped off the police to H. H. Holmes’s illegal dealings was shot by a Chicago police officer. The warden at the prison where Holmes had been held killed himself. The office of the district attorney (who argued the famous case) caught on fire. The only item to survive the blaze intact was a photo of Holmes.
Patrick Quinlan — the former caretaker of the castle who, after Holmes, knew the most about the haunted building — committed suicide in 1914.
He left a one-sentence note:
“I could not sleep.”
After this tour through the H.H. Holmes hotel and his gruesome murders, read about the hospital serial killer who was known as “The Angel of Death”. Or discover the tale of “Lobster Boy,” the circus act turned murderer.