The Real Story Of Paul Vario, The Gangster Behind Paul Sorvino’s ‘Goodfellas’ Character

Published June 4, 2018
Updated March 28, 2024

As the capo of the Lucesse crime family, Paul Vario was not a man you wanted to cross.

Paul Vario Mugshot

Wikimedia CommonsLucchese Family capo Paul Vario.

Born in New York City in 1914, Paul Vario began his life of crime when he was just a kid. He did his first stint in prison when he was 11 years old and during the course of his youth would do time for crimes ranging from burglary to tax evasion.

As he got older, he was arrested less frequently; not because he had had a change of heart, but because people became too afraid to bring charges against him. As a caporegime of the Lucchese crime family, Paul Vario reigned over the Brownsville neighborhood in Brooklyn with an iron fist.

Paul Vario As Capo

As capo, Paul Vario oversaw all of the gambling and extortion rackets in the area and kept order among the thugs who worked there. He also owned several legitimate businesses in Brooklyn, including a pizzeria and a florist.

Henry Hill (Vario’s former associate turned stool-pigeon) recalled how his boss was meticulous about ensuring nothing could ever be traced back to him, advising his young associate “Never put your name on anything!”

All of the legitimate businesses he owned were registered to his brothers; the mob boss never even had his own telephone and refused to hold meetings with multiple people.

Paul Vario’s gang had a reputation as one of the most violent in the city and the boss himself was renowned for his vicious temper. Standing at 6 feet tall and weighing 240 pounds, the capo was slow to anger, but when he did, things got ugly fast.

One night while he was out to dinner with his wife Phyllis, the waiter accidentally spilled some wine all over her dress. After the unfortunate server attempted to mop the spill up with a dirty rag, Vario lost his temper and dealt the man a few blows before he was able to escape to the safety of the kitchen.

The restaurant staff attempted to hold Vario off with various pots and pans, but he returned with backup later in the evening. As Hill recalled, “We were chasing waiters and breaking heads all over Brooklyn that night.”

Paul Vario In Goodfellas

The exploits of Paul Vario’s crew made up the real story behind Martin Scorsese’s 1990 film Goodfellas, the screenplay of which was based on Hill’s own biography, as told to author Nicholas Pileggi in his book Wiseguy. Vario became ‘Paul Cicero,’ portrayed by Paul Sorvino. The film largely depicts the exploits of Lucchese associates Hill, Jimmy Burke, and Tommy DeSimone. In its final third, it revolves around the 1978 Lufthansa heist when masked thieves stole what would today amount to $22 million dollars of cash and jewelry from a vault at JFK airport in New York.

The heist was the biggest in United States history; none of the stolen goods were ever recovered and the FBI was not able to formally charge anyone until over three decades later.

Lufthansa Heist

Wikimedia CommonsJFK Airport in the 1970s, when the Lufthansa heist was pulled off.

Because Paul Vario himself was never charged in relation to the 1978 heist, there is no hard evidence documenting his involvement, only unverified information gleaned from informants.

Vario’s gang had long been involved in stealing cargo from JFK, they did it so often that Hill described the airport as their version of “Citibank.” At the time of the heist, Vario was down in Florida where he had been living on parole after serving in federal prison in Pennsylvania.

According to the informants, Vario gave the OK for the heist via a telephone call to his “representative” in New York (breaking his own long-sacred rule), putting the one of the most infamous crimes in American history into action with a simple “do it.”

Although Vario was never charged in relation to the Lufthansa heist, his life of crime eventually caught up with him. His former protégé, Henry Hill, gave up his old boss as part of a deal with the feds in order to save his own skin.

Paul Vario died in 1988 in a Texas prison, where he was still doing time on a conviction Hill had helped bring about.

After learning about Paul Vario, read the story of Karen Hill, wife of Henry Hill. Then, check out the story of Billy Batts.

Gina Dimuro
A graduate of New York University, Gina Dimuro is a New York-based writer and translator.
John Kuroski
John Kuroski is the editorial director of All That's Interesting. He graduated from New York University with a degree in history, earning a place in the Phi Alpha Theta honor society for history students. An editor at All That's Interesting since 2015, his areas of interest include modern history and true crime.
Citation copied
Cite This Article
Dimuro, Gina. "The Real Story Of Paul Vario, The Gangster Behind Paul Sorvino’s ‘Goodfellas’ Character.", June 4, 2018, Accessed May 19, 2024.