Last year, reports said that Kenya announced that it would use the death penalty for illegal poaching. Here's how and why those reports were wrong.
Over the past year and a half, dozens of news outlets — including All That’s Interesting (see below) — have published stories claiming that Kenya would begin using the death penalty against wildlife poachers. However, a new report from AFP states that these stories are false.
According to AFP, the false stories about the death penalty began appearing in May 2018 with reports from sites like News360 and The Independent (referencing a report from China’s Xinhua news agency).
While such reports cite statements from Tourism Minister Najib Balala describing the implementation of the death penalty at a meeting in Laikipia County on May 10, AFP has found that Balala made no such statements. In fact, AFP found that Balala was not even at the meeting in the first place.
Furthermore, AFP spoke to Balala’s representative at the meeting, former director of research monitoring and strategic initiative Patrick Omondi, as well as Balala himself, and confirmed that no such statements were made and that Kenya indeed is not planning to use the death penalty for poachers.
“That is misinformation,” Omondi said.
And as Balala said:
“I have been pushing for harsher punishment because what we currently have does not add up at all. A kilo of ivory costs about $60,000 and the fine for a poacher who caught many kilos of ivory is only about $199,000. If you compare this, it seems to be a mere slap on the wrist. But this does not mean death penalty — that, I assure you, was taken out of context.”
So while Balala may indeed believe that stricter consequences are in order for poachers, the death penalty is never what he proposed.
See our original story below:
Our Previous Reporting
Last year, the Kenyan government announced a bold proposition to protect its vulnerable wildlife: using the death penalty against illegal poachers. Now, according to News 360, lawmakers are aiming to fast-track the passing of this legislation.
The current law in Kenya makes it illegal to kill endangered animals in the country. In addition, the 2013 Wildlife Conservation Act also carries a life sentence or $200,000 fine against illegal poachers. But these legislative efforts have not been enough.
“This [fining and life sentence] has not been deterrence enough to curb poaching,” said Najib Balala, Kenya’s Cabinet Secretary for its Ministry of Tourism and Wildlife.
The decision to set the death penalty as punishment for illegal poaching is a controversial one that has invited both praise and criticism against the Kenyan government. The move has also drawn the ire of the United Nations, which opposes the death penalty for all crimes and has been pushing for the phasing-out of capital punishment worldwide.
Kenya has a highly diverse wildlife population and is home to a number of beloved yet often killed animals, such as giraffes, cheetahs, rhinoceros, and elephants, with the latter two animals the most threatened because of their desired horns and tusks among poachers.
The good news is that poaching has seen a big decline in Kenya, largely due to increased conservation efforts and law enforcement initiatives. According to the Ministry of Tourism and Wildlife, rhinoceros poaching in Kenya has declined by 85 percent compared to 2013 while elephant poaching has dwindled by 78 percent.
However, Kenya’s beloved wildlife does remain in danger.
As it stands, there are only an estimated 1,000 black rhinos left in Kenya and the elephant population remains around 34,000. Animal advocacy group Save the Rhino reported that there were at least 23 rhinos and 156 elephants that were killed by poachers in the country between 2016 and 2017 alone.
These estimates do not account for yearly poaching that also continues to occur in other African countries, like the Democratic Republic of the Congo and South Africa.
According to a report by the African Wildlife Foundation (AWF), almost 70 percent of illegal ivory that is sold and exported ends up in China, where these it can sell for up to $1,000 a pound.
Sanctioning capital punishment as sentencing for illegal poaching acts might sound extreme, but some in Kenya feel that it’s an appropriate response to such an alarming problem.
Besides the threat of extinction, we are already seeing other consequences for animal populations as a result of uncurbed poaching, including rapid biological evolutions among female African elephants that are increasingly being born without tusks.
So far, Kenya is the only African country set to officially implement the death penalty as punishment for illegal poaching.
Next, read about the weird history of elephants used as a cruel method of capital punishment. Next up, read about the $8 million-worth of illegal ivory that was destroyed in New York’s Central Park.